Intrigue is thick on the eve before the Big Game. Just what exactly does Motorola have up their sleeve? Will any or all of the Doritos (consumer-generated) ads make it to a top slot in the USA TODAY Ad Meter rankings, thereby creating a potentially huge windfall for their creators?
And for goodness sake, will we get to see some Clydesdales this year?
Anheuser-Busch has been toying with our emotions for weeks, first saying “No Clydesdales” and then saying, “ok, MAYBE we’ll let you see them…”
Well at least in terms of the last question, we do have an answer. As those who have recently visited Budweiser’s Facebook fan page already know, the equine rock stars of the advertising world will appear in a new ad during the Game, and you can even get a sneak preview of it here.
So now that we can at least relax on that front, here are some final tips and guidelines for really “getting into” this year’s Super Bowl advertising. Half the fun is knowing the inside scoop! In addition, the last section of this blog post explains how to join the upcoming #SBadwatch2010 TweetChat as well as participate in the post-game 4-SQUARE™ Super Bowl 2010 Ad Survey.
Who’s advertising this year? Are any of the “usual suspects” gone? Any notable “newbies”?
Expect to see a lot (in seconds on the screen) from Anheuser-Busch and Coca-Cola. There may be up to 9 movie trailers combined from Disney, Universal and Paramount. It will feel like there is a huge amount of automotive advertising, with spots from Hyundai, Kia, Audi, Honda, Volkswagen and Dodge. (Yes, that’s right. For the first time since 2005 a Dodge model will be advertised in the Super Bowl. Last time it was the Dodge Magnum; this year it is the Dodge Charger.)
With so many automotive manufacturers showing up for the Super Bowl, it’s notable that Subaru, riding high on their incredible sales performance of 2009, chose the “road less traveled” and opted to advertise on Animal Planet’s Puppy Bowl instead!
(Subaru led the industry in 2009 with a U.S. sales advance of 5%, increasing market share to 2.1% from 1.4% in 2008—all in an overall market that plunged 21%.)
Advertisers who in years past had a big presence in the Super Bowl yet are gone this year include FedEx, Pepsico and General Motors. There are no major banks advertising; the only financial services firm will be E-Trade.
“Newbies” include Boost Mobile, HomeAway (for vacation rentals), and the already hotly-debated Focus on the Family. (Last year newbie Cash4Gold received much attention for seeming like a “brand out of water” amidst all the fancy Super Bowl creative seen from more traditional advertisers. Which newbie ad this year will raise eyebrows?)
What’s new in consumer-generated content this year?
Two major players have chosen to go with ads created by consumers. Doritos, continuing with their “Crash the Super Bowl” contest, once again invited people to submit self-made Doritos ads. They will air the three top winning ads during the Game, and if any of these make it to a top-3 slot in the USA TODAY Ad Meter the creator will win major cash. There is a potential payout, if somehow all three ads place in the Ad Meter poll, of $5 MILLION DOLLARS. Over 4,000 ads were submitted to the contest this year.
CareerBuilder, while perhaps not in the same league in terms of financial prizes, will feature with great fanfare the winner of their “Hire My TV Ad” contest. Three finalist ads, all highlighting how CareerBuilder can help rescue someone from a miserable work environment, were posted online for voting and the final winner will be unveiled at the Super Bowl.
Interesting marketing moves to check out before/after/during the Big Game:
1. Callaway Golf will be the stand-alone sponsor of the 5:00 pm—5:30 pm half hour ahead of kickoff, and will have “product exposure” on the CBS set during the time period. Phil Mickelson (their primary endorser) is slated to appear in an additional segment to run during the sponsored programming.
2. Bridgestone is sponsoring the game’s halftime show (and will have spots during the game as well).
3. Intel is title sponsor of the post-game show. (They’re running one 30 second spot during the game, then two after the game).
4. Sun Life (a Canadian financial services firm) bought the naming rights to the stadium in which the Super Bowl will be played. They will leverage in-broadcast name mentions with TV spots that will air during the Super Bowl pre-game and post-game shows. (Note, this stadium has had many names, including Dolphins Stadium, “Land Shark Stadium” (briefly), Pro Player Stadium and Joe Robbie Stadium.)
5. Ford, while missing from the game, has bought spots to run in the pre-game shows.
6. Hyundai plans to run EIGHT COMMERCIALS in total if one counts before, during and after the game. Plus the brand will sponsor the pre-game kickoff show for the second year in a row. The 2009 Advertising Age Marketer of the Year is determined not to lose any momentum!
7. McDonald’s will show a remake of the famous 1993 Super Bowl commercial “The Showdown.” The original featured Michael Jordan and Larry Bird competing for a Big Mac. In the remake LeBron James and Dwight Howard are on the court. A teaser of this ad can be found here, but the full 60-second spot will air during the pre-game.
How to Join the Super Bowl TweetChat, #SBadwatch2010:
I will be tweeting with others on Twitter in real-time during the game at #SBadwatch2010, and hope you will join us! For those who may be unfamiliar with TweetChats (including some of my current Marketing 715 students), here are the instructions you will need to participate.
(Note, I recommend doing this earlier, before the game, so that you can get acquainted with the speed and general interface. Particularly once the game begins things can move really fast and become hard to follow if one is inexperienced.)
1. You should use your Twitter login to log on to http://tweetchat.com/.
2. Enter SBadwatch2010 into the search bar up at the top (i.e., in the box that follows the hashtag).
This will get you into the chat. Then, Happy Tweeting! I can’t wait to find out your reactions to what these advertisers have in store for us.
Finally, instructions for the 4-SQUARE™ Super Bowl 2010 Ad Survey (to be found at thinkfeelsaydo.com):
Once the game is over we will need to ask: So how did all of this add up? From a marketing perspective, who were the winners? Losers?
To answer that question, it’s important to ask a more fundamental question: what makes a good Super Bowl ad? Or for that matter, what makes a Super Bowl ad tank? Consider a 4-SQUARE™ assessment. Four conditions that set the stage for success or failure are:
1. Exposure –Were the right people exposed to the ad?
When did it appear? What quarter? Were people actually in the room and able to look at the ad? Or were they zapping to Puppy Bowl, or fighting with the Colts fans in the room, or (really) drunk, or otherwise not available?
2. Attention –Did the right people pay attention to the ad?
Did the ad command and hold attention? Did it break through, and maintain its hold on the viewer, all the way to the end?
3. Comprehension –Did the right people “get” the ad?
Did viewers understand the story or gist of the ad, and take away the key point the marketer was hoping to convey? The point could be anything, from “we’re the best product” to “we’re all-American” to “we’re cool” to “you need to go to our website right now!” But the ad should make the consumer think, feel, say or do something as intended by the marketer. If the ad didn’t make something happen in the consumer, it’s dead-on-arrival.
4. Integration –Did the ad ladder up to, or connect well with, other marketing tactics?
Did the ad connect the consumer with other social media, other consumers, other marketing tactics? In other words, was the ad just one (perhaps major) link in a chain, connecting the consumer with other marketing activities such as going to Facebook, going to the marketer’s website, entering a sweepstakes, redeeming a voucher for a free gift, or just talking to other consumers about the ad (online and/or in person)?
Come back to this website, thinkfeelsaydo.com, shortly after the game (or Monday morning if you prefer your own version of “Monday-Morning Quarterbacking”). My handy-dandy 4-SQUARE™ Super Bowl 2010 Ad Survey will be live and waiting for you, where you can rate the ads shown during the 2010 Super Bowl on the FOUR KEY SUCCESS CRITERIA listed above.
For those who don’t get a chance to see the ads during the actual Super Bowl, all ads that air can be found at CBS Sports beginning immediately after the completion of the game.
I’ll post the 4-SQUARE™ survey results in this blog soon after, as well as provide more analysis and identify the ads I believe should win 2010 “Best in Show”/“Worst in Show” awards.
And now: Countdown to SUPER BOWL XLIV on television, and #SBadwatch2010 on Twitter!
Think, Feel, Say, Do 